Skip to main content

A challenge

This is my new adventure in blogging... it may work out... it may not.  Let's wait and see.

An idea on my mind lately is challenge. Actually mostly what's been on my mind is the opposite of challenge... the lack of challenge, the dross of  'at-level', and how scared we teachers seem to be of giving our students things that genuinely challenge them.

Take reading for example... why not give kids something to read that they can actually get their teeth into, why stick to the golden rule of 90-95% accuracy? Why not let kids struggle, just a bit, just for a while - would it hurt?  Why are we so scared of  giving kids hard stuff to read? What is the benefit of so-called lateral extension (in less PC terms, making kids read 'the whole level', or in even less PC terms, just not letting them go 'up')? Why just let them go for it? Imagine what that must feel like for a keen, capable reader... knowing there's a whole world of interesting books out there that you are not allowed to touch just in case you find them a bit tricky. How else can kids learn resilience, persistance, risk-taking, trying hard, toughing things out, puzzling things out... etc?  Or discover new authors, new ideas, new worlds etc.

In my gifted classes I see two distinct groups of children - those who have been challenged, risen to the challenge, and have learnt how to embrace / tackle challenges with some skill and most importantly some gusto. Then there are those who haven't (for whatever reason) been challenged - these children generally shrink away from challenge, they are scared, unsure, uncertain, uncomfortable and they don't know how to manage those feelings. They variously dumb-down (so as not to implicitly ask for challenge), act-out (to resist challenge), shut-down (again to resist challenge), and in any way possible, don't rise to the occasion.

It annoys me profoundly, but on a personal level, I can sympathize. I can count of the fingers of one hand times when I felt challenged at school. Sometimes the challenge was simply the interest / novelty value in learning something new, but mostly it was only because the material was frightening(war, volcanoes, the holocaust, earthquakes etc) or the classroom was frightening (noisy, busy) or the kids in the classroom (too many of them) or even the teacher was scary, but actual intellectual challenge was absent.

So I remember in crystal clear detail how I felt (and what I did) when I faced what I think were my first ever intellectual challenges - in my first year at unversity. Newly turned 16, I was introduced to a more grown up world, with big words, big ideas, big opportunities and what was most exciting, a big library - all of it full of HARD STUFF!!!! I was terrified, felt sick, loved it, was obsessively excited and scared in turns, and loved all of it. What a shame I had to wait until university to experience challenge. In my second year I didn't manage the challenge that well, but managed to recover my composure soon after.

I always wonder about what my school life would have been like if I had experienced genuine challenge (not just feeling a bit interested a few times, or feeling scared quite a lot of times). Perhaps I might have learned to like school....? What a novelty THAT would have been!

So, my challenge is... be brave and add some challenge to your teaching life. You might just hit the spot with someone whose spot needs to be hit :)


Popular posts from this blog

Celebrating Success - From the Horses' Mouths

Celebrate Gifted Aotearoa NZ: Catalysts of Success is a great theme for Gifted Awareness Week 2018. It's positive, hopeful, reflective and fun! This theme combines some interesting ideas, and I asked myMindPlus classes (one-day-a-week specialist programme for gifted learners, part of the New Zealand Centre for Gifted Education) what they thought about this theme for Gifted Awareness Week.  So here come some ideas from the horses' mouths... 
Firstly, celebrating. Gifted Awareness Week is indeed a week of celebration for those of us who are connected to gifted education, as learners, parents, teachers, or as interested parties. It gives us all of a specific time and reason to recognise and feel proud of our gifted learners. Having this specific time helps us to get past some of the reasons why gifted learners (and perhaps also their parents) can be reluctant to celebrate their success.  Here are some of the things my students said: 
⁃ “Sometimes my success isn't recognised as …

A Message on a Post-It

Not long ago in my MindPlus class, we were talking about being gifted and what that means for us. Instead of talking, one student quietly wrote on a post-it ‘I don’t really feel like I fit in at school’ and stuck it on the wall. This innocuous little post-it kick-started a torrent of ‘me too’ comments and we talked at length about this meant. Whilst fitting in is not the same as a sense of belonging, the two can go hand-in-hand. Children talked about not feeling 'right', not fitting with others, being misunderstood, being different, not being able to be themselves, and not meeting others like them as factors that contributed towards their sense of not belonging. 
As a teacher, a parent, and a human, I felt devastated for these young people carrying the burden of not fitting in, not feeling part of things, not belonging.  I wondered what it was that made them feel so ill at ease?  I wondered what steps we could take to enhance belonging in our classrooms?
Some of my ponderings br…

Like-mindedness...inclusion...and us.

Associate Professor Tracy Riley’s recent research, shared in a SENG article, Thinking Along the Same Lines, and to be further explored at the upcoming NZAGC conference, puts like-mindedness in the spotlight.
Like-mindedness is an important part of gifted education. The benefits of grouping gifted children together, creating like-minded environments, are both intellectual and social. Intellectually, like-minded students can work together at a faster pace, in greater depth, can challenge and question each other in order to bolster their individual and collective learning. Research by Adams-Byers, Whitsell and Moon (2004) found that gifted students saw the academic advantages in learning with like-minded peers as being challenge, fast pace, quality and depth of discussion, and lack of repetition of content.  Sandra Kaplan highlights that in like-minded groups, students can share perspectives and ideas that can be more readily understood, without the need for protracted explanation. This s…